Poulton |
|
Poulton (1999), 177 D.L.R. (4th) 507 (Ont. C.A.)Poulton (1998), 108 O.A.C. 67 (Ont. Div.Ct.) |
%20177%20DLR%20(4th)%20507%20(Ont.C.A.).png)
%20108%20OAC%2067%20(Ont.Div.Ct.).png)
|
Peter A. Simm was sole counsel for the successful Applicant for Judicial Review in Poulton v. ORC (1998, Ont. Div. Ct.; varied only re costs 1999, Ont. C.A.). The Divisional Court’s decision, vindicating one of North America’s leading standardbred horse trainers, notably precluded a rehearing by the ORC, saying “it is impossible to remedy the prejudice”. The ORC had effectively thwarted the possibility of having an independent lab test the remainder of an allegedly incriminating equine urine sample. Poulton is cited in 9 Canadian legal textbooks, and in 3 appellate court or judicial review decisions, the most recent being in 2016. Media coverage included articles in the Globe & Mail and The Lawyer’s Weekly . Full cite: Poulton v. Ontario (Racing Commission) (1998), 108 O.A.C. 67, 1998 CarswellOnt 760, [1998] O.J. No. 709 (Ont. Div. Ct.); varied only as to costs, 1999 CanLII 1398, 177 D.L.R. (4th) 507, 123 O.A.C. 352, 18 Admin. L.R. (3d) 1, 1999 CarswellOnt 2607, [1999] O.J. No. 3152 (Ont. C.A.). (Co-counsel with C. Chop.)
|
|
Poulton costs appeal (1999), 123 O.A.C. 352 (Ont. C.A.)Poulton costs appeal (1999), 18 Admin. L.R. (3d) 1 (Ont. C.A.)
Administrative Law in Canada (6th ed.) - Blake - cites Poulton, Richmond twice, McNamaraBC Administrative Law Practice Manual cites Poulton, RichmondCosts - CED Ont (4th ed.) - Dunlop - sums Poulton & MegensGaming - CED Ont (4th ed.) - Leech & Winans - sums Poulton, Megens, McNamaraJudicial Review of Administrative Action in Canada - Brown & Evans - cites Poulton twice; Megens six times; Richmond 5 times; McNamara twice; Schickedanz twice; SymtronLaw of Costs (2nd ed.) - Orkin - cites: Poulton 3 times; Megens; CollinsOntario Annual Practice 2012-13 - Carthy et al. - cites Poulton & Megens; sums MorrayPractice & Procedure Before Administrative Tribunals - Macaulay, Sprague & Sossin - cite Poulton twice, McKay-Clements, McNamara twice, MegensSports - CED Ont (4th ed.) - Barnes - sums Poulton, Schickedanz, Megens, McNamara
37 Advocates’ Quarterly 40 (2011) - Kligman paper cites Poulton, discusses Megens & McNamaraThe Litigator (Dec 2009) 103-108 - Brandow paper cites Poulton24 Tort Law Review 80 (2016) - Marin paper cites Poulton63 University of Toronto Faculty of Law Review 111 (2005) - Gourlay paper cites Poulton |
%20123%20OAC%20352%20(Ont.C.A.).png)
%2018%20Admin%20LR%20(3d)%201%20(Ont.C.A.).png)
%20Guardian%201998-03-02%20-%20Poulton%20cleared.png)
 Guardian 1998-03-02 - Poulton cleared.png)
%20-%20Kligman%20paper%20disc%20Megens%20McNamara%20cite%20Poulton.png)
%20103-108%20-%20Brandow%20paper%20cites%20Poulton.png)
%20-%20Marin%20paper%20cites%20Poulton.png)
%20-%20Gourlay%20paper%20cites%20Poulton..png)